/* for 1st slide */
/* for 2nd slide */
/* for 3rd slide */
/* for 4th slide */

Sunday, August 22, 2010

Are they Really Floods or Something Else?





The important debate on global warming under UN auspices provides but a partial picture of climate change; in addition to the devastating impacts of greenhouse gas emissions on the ozone layer, the World's climate can now be
modified as part of a new generation of sophisticated "non-lethal weapons." Both the Americans and the Russians have developed capabilities to manipulate the World's climate.

In the US, the technology is being perfected under the High-frequency Active Aural Research Program (HAARP) as part of the ("Star Wars") Strategic Defence Initiative (SDI). Recent scientific evidence suggests that HAARP is fully operational and has the ability of potentially triggering floods, droughts, hurricanes and earthquakes.

HAARP IS A MASS DESTRUCTIVE WEAPON - NOT PART OF ANY NEGOTIATIONS

From a military standpoint, HAARP is a weapon of mass destruction. Potentially, it constitutes an instrument of conquest capable of selectively destabilising agricultural and ecological systems of entire regions.

While there is no evidence that this deadly technology has been used, surely the United Nations should be addressing the issue of "environmental warfare" alongside the debate on the climatic impacts of greenhouse gases.

Despite a vast body of scientific knowledge, the issue of deliberate climatic manipulations for military use has never been explicitly part of the UN agenda on climate change. Neither the official delegations nor the environmental action groups participating in the Hague Conference on Climate Change (CO6) (November 2000) have raised the broad issue of "weather warfare" or "environmental modification techniques (ENMOD)" as relevant to an understanding of climate change.

The clash between official negotiators, environmentalists and American business lobbies has centered on Washington's outright refusal to abide by commitments on carbon dioxide reduction targets under the 1997 Kyoto protocol.(1) The impacts of military technologies on the World's climate are not an object of discussion or concern. Narrowly confined to greenhouse gases, the ongoing debate on climate change serves Washington's strategic and defense objectives.

"WEATHER WARFARE"

World renowned scientist Dr. Rosalie Bertell confirms that "US military scientists are working on weather systems as a potential weapon. The methods include
the enhancing of storms and the diverting of vapor rivers in the Earth's atmosphere to produce targeted droughts or floods."(2)

Already in the 1970s, former National Security advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski had foreseen in his book "Between Two Ages" that:

"Technology will make available, to the leaders of major nations, techniques for conducting secret warfare, of which only a bare minimum of the security forces need be appraised... Techniques of weather modification could be employed to produce prolonged periods of drought or storm. "

Marc Filterman, a former French military officer, outlines several types of "unconventional weapons" using radio frequencies. He refers to "weather war," indicating that the U.S. and the Soviet Union had already "mastered the know-how needed to unleash sudden climate changes (hurricanes, drought) in the early 1980s." (3) These technologies make it "possible to trigger atmospheric disturbances by using Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) radar [waves]." (4)

A simulation study of future defense "scenarios" commissioned for the US Air Force calls for: "US aerospace forces to 'own the weather' by capitalizing on emerging technologies and focusing development of those technologies to war-fighting applications." From enhancing friendly operations or disrupting those of the enemy via small-scale tailoring of natural weather patterns to complete dominance of global communications and counterspace control, weather-modification offers the war fighter a wide-range of possible options to defeat or coerce an adversary. In the United States, weather-modification will likely become a part of national security policy with both domestic and international applications. Our government will pursue such a policy, depending on its interests, at various levels. (5)

THE HIGH-FREQUENCY ACTIVE AURAL RESEARCH PROGRAM - HAARP

The High-Frequency Active Aural Research Program (HAARP) based in Gokoma Alaska-jointly managed by the US Air Force and the US Navy-is part of a new generation of sophisticated weaponry under the US Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI). Operated by the Air Force Research Laboratory's Space Vehicles Directorate, HAARP constitutes a system of powerful antennas capable of creating "controlled local modifications of the ionosphere".

Scientist Dr. Nicholas Begich-actively involved in the public campaign against HAARP-describes HAARP as: "A super-powerful radiowave-beaming technology that lifts areas of the ionosphere (upper layer of the atmosphere) by focusing a beam and heating those areas. Electromagnetic waves then bounce back onto earth and penetrate everything-living and dead." (6)

Dr. Rosalie Bertell depicts HAARP as "a gigantic heater that can cause major disruption in the ionosphere, creating not just holes, but long incisions in the protective layer that keeps deadly radiation from bombarding the planet." (7)

MISLEADING PUBLIC OPINION

HAARP has been presented to public opinion as a program of scientific and academic research. US military documents seem to suggest, however, that HAARP's main objective is to "exploit the ionosphere for Department of Defense purposes." (8) Without explicitly referring to the HAARP program, a US Air Force study points to the use of "induced ionospheric modifications" as a means of altering weather patterns as well as disrupting enemy communications and radar.(9)

According to Dr. Rosalie Bertell, HAARP is part of a integrated weapons' system, which has potentially devastating environmental consequences: "It is related to fifty years of intensive and increasingly destructive programs to understand and control the upper atmosphere. It would be rash not to associate HAARP with the space laboratory construction which is separately being planned by the United States. HAARP is an integral part of a long history of space research and development of a deliberate military nature.

The military implications of combining these projects is alarming. The ability of the HAARP / Spacelab/ rocket combination to deliver very large amount of energy, comparable to a nuclear bomb, anywhere on earth via laser and particle beams, are frightening. The project is likely to be "sold" to the public as a space shield against incoming weapons, or, for the more gullible, a device for repairing the ozone layer. (10)

In addition to weather manipulation, HAARP has a number of related uses: "HAARP could contribute to climate change by intensively bombarding the atmosphere with high-frequency rays. Returning low-frequency waves at high intensity could also affect people's brains, and effects on tectonic movements cannot be ruled out. (11).

More generally, HAARP has the ability of modifying the World's electro-magnetic field. It is part of an arsenal of "electronic weapons" which US military researchers consider a "gentler and kinder warfare". (12)

WEAPONS OF THE NEW WORLD ORDER

HAARP is part of the weapons arsenal of the New World Order under the Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI). From military command points in the US, entire national economies could potentially be destabilized through climatic manipulations. More importantly, the latter can be implemented without the knowledge of the enemy, at minimal cost and without engaging military personnel and equipment as in a conventional war. The use of HAARP-if it were to be applied-could have potentially devastating impacts on the World's climate.

Responding to US economic and strategic interests, it could be used to selectively modify climate in different parts of the World resulting in the destabilization of agricultural and ecological systems. It is also worth noting that the US Department of Defense has allocated substantial resources to the development of intelligence and monitoring systems on weather changes. NASA and the Department of Defense's National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) are working on "imagery for studies of flooding, erosion, land-slide hazards, earthquakes, ecological zones, weather forecasts, and climate change" with data relayed from satellites. (13)

POLICY INERTIA OF THE UNITED NATIONS

According to the Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) signed at the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro:

"States have, in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations and the principles of international law, the responsibility to ensure that activities within their jurisdiction or control do not cause damage to the environment of other States or of areas beyond the limits of national jurisdiction." (14).

It is also worth recalling that an international Convention ratified by the UN General Assembly in 1997 bans "military or other hostile use of environmental modification techniques having widespread, long-lasting or severe effects." (15) Both the US and the Soviet Union were signatories to the Convention. The Convention defines "environmental modification techniques" as referring to any technique for changing-through the deliberate manipulation of natural processes-the dynamics, composition or structure of the earth, including its biota, lithosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere or of outer space." (16) Why then did the UN-disregarding the 1977 ENMOD Convention as well as its own charter-decide to exclude from its agenda climatic changes resulting from military programs?

EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT ACKNOWLEDGES IMPACT OF HAARP

In February 1998, responding to a report of Mrs. Maj. Britt Theorin-Swedish MEP and longtime peace advocate--, the European Parliament's Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defense Policy held public hearings in Brussels on the HAARP program.(17) The Committee's "Motion for Resolution" submitted to the European Parliament: "Considers HAARP by virtue of its far-reaching impact on the environment to be a global concern and calls for its legal, ecological and ethical implications to be examined by an international independent body; [the Committee] regrets the repeated refusal of the United States Administration to give evidence to the public hearing into the environmental and public risks [of&] the HAARP program." (18.)

The Committee's request to draw up a "Green Paper" on "the environmental impacts of military activities", however, was casually dismissed on the grounds that the European Commission lacks the required jurisdiction to delve into "the links between environment and defense". (19) Brussels was anxious to avoid a showdown with Washington.

FULLY OPERATIONAL

While there is no concrete evidence of HAARP having been used, scientific findings suggest that it is at present fully operational. What this means is that HAARP could potentially be applied by the US military to selectively modify the climate of an "unfriendly nation" or "rogue state" with a view to destabilizing its national economy. Agricultural systems in both developed and developing countries are already in crisis as a result of New World Order policies including market deregulation, commodity dumping, etc. Amply documented, IMF and World Bank "economic medicine" imposed on the Third World and the countries of the former Soviet block has largely contributed to the destabilization of domestic agriculture. In turn, the provisions of the World Trade Organization (WTO) have supported the interests of a handful of Western agri-biotech conglomerates in their quest to impose genetically modified (GMO) seeds on farmers throughout the World.

It is important to understand the linkage between the economic, strategic and military processes of the New World Order. In the above context, climatic manipulations under the HAARP program (whether accidental or deliberate) would inevitably exacerbate these changes by weakening national economies, destroying infrastructure and potentially triggering the bankruptcy of farmers over vast areas. Surely national governments and the United Nations should address
the possible consequences of HAARP and other "non-lethal weapons" on climate change.

Saturday, August 21, 2010

Pakistan Floods: Causes and Consequences


Pakistan Floods: Causes and Consequences

August 19, 2010
Diagnosing the right causes is perhaps the first step towards suggesting an appropriate framework of action. As two thousand people are being reported dead and twenty million severely affected, the recent deluge in Pakistan is invariably drawing attention from various quarters. While the pro-dam lobby is advocating the cause of Kalabagh dam, with Shams ul Mulk, former chief of WAPDA, claiming that the dam could have mitigated the impact of the deluge, the United States for its own reasons is strategizing to leverage its aid policy in order to win the hearts and minds of the Pakistanis. The Pakistan Army meanwhile has stepped up relief and rehabilitation programmes with great visibility and political gimmick. However, even as the floods in Pakistan continue to leave its disaster footprint every day, the causes which contributed to these ravaging floods need to be addressed by the Pakistani establishment.

What caused floods in Pakistan? While some hold monsoon patterns and heavy rainfall responsible for flash floods, others consider climate change, dams and deforestation as playing the trigger for the floods. Between these vying explanations the facts available on the existing timber mafia in Pakistan are the most telling. According to a story featured in Al Jazeera English (August 8, 2010), the provincial head of the National Disaster Management Authority has been quoted as saying that denudation is one of the main reasons for aggravating the floods as only 5.2 per cent of land in Pakistan is covered by forests. A local organisation, Sarhad Awami Forestry Ittehad (SAFI), has claimed that in parts of Malakand Agency, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, “more than 70 percent of forests were illegally cut down between 2007 and 2009, when Pakistani Taliban controlled the region.” Another report in The Guardian (August 12, 2010) claims that the flooding has been intense in areas where the timber mafia is active. It states that the felled trees stacked in ravines for the purpose of smuggling were dislodged by the force of water, thus sweeping away bridges, people and weakening the dam walls along its way. In fact, according to reports, the timber filled the Tarbela dam reservoir, thus blocking any storage space.

Down South, Sindh reverberates with a similar story. While the villagers and the local people have been resisting the landlords and the Army from illegal encroachment of land, the state response has been almost flippant. As per the available facts, forests cover only 2.3 per cent of the total land area of Sindh and reports claim that the deteriorating condition of the forests refrain them from contributing to timber, fuel wood or fodder. Reports have been continuously flooding the media that illegal tree cutting has been carried out at a large scale along the canal banks and the riverine forests in Northern Sindh. The timber mafia whose actions often go unchecked due to their links with the political leadership in North Sindh has been accused of disturbing the delicate balance in the eco-system.

The timber mafia though is just one reminder of the gravity of man’s tinkering with nature. Its uninhibited sustenance in the polity of Pakistan is a strong pointer to the still existing feudal set-up which very much governs Pakistani society. Floods in Pakistan in the coming months could bring these festering contradictions to the fore with some consequence. The resentment would only build up as inequity and disproportionate distribution of resources further increases. This is because one of the most visible impacts of the floods would be seen in the agricultural sector which along with being the backbone of the Pakistani economy also sustains the livelihood of the majority of the rural population. Agriculture employs round 47 per cent of the population and around 60 per cent of the annual national foreign exchange earnings come from this sector alone. The major crops in Pakistan are rice (2.6 million hectares), maize (1 million hectares), jowar (0.3 million hectares) cotton (3 million hectares), wheat (8.6 million hectares), and sugarcane (1 million hectares). Low production of any of the major crops could adversely impact the Pakistani economy especially in terms of balance of payments. If one casts a look at the trail of destruction in Pakistan, the floods have severely impacted Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa which is the main producer of sugarcane and maize, South Punjab which is the main producer of cotton and wheat, and Sindh which is the main producer of cotton and rice.

Moreover, as resentment towards feudals is very much prevalent in all the four provinces, any lack of outreach by the federal and provincial governments to alleviate the plight of the common men and women might aggravate further anti-state tendencies. The Seraiki movement in South Punjab has often raised voices against the discrimination that the Seraiki belt has been witnessing over the past years. Presence of the Taliban in Sindh and South Punjab are too well known to be reiterated here. The plight of the farmers and the majority of rural population can also be gauged from the land distribution pattern in Pakistan. Peasant eviction in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa has given rise to collectives like kisan jirga and Mazdoor Kisan Party. In Punjab, the peasantry is known for its belligerent resistance. The Okara farm dispute in 2003 is a reminder of the seething anger peasants feel against the hegemonic monopolization of land and resources by the Army. Meanwhile, exploitation of Haris in Sindh, who often articulate their demand through Sindh Hari committees, is also a pointer to the iniquitous distribution of resources. Not only around 80 to 85 per cent of land is Sindh is operated by tenants, but also around 1.6 million acres of government land in Kotri barrage and 1.1 million acres in Guddu barrage were allotted to non-sindhis in the 1960s. Thus the peasants of Sindh constituting the majority of population would be facing desperate days as they have no alternative livelihood to bank upon. As some media reports rightly point out, the real problem would start when authorities start to pay compensation and the haris (peasants) would be asked to provide ownership documents, which they obviously do not possess as the land belongs to landlords most of whom have available resources to cope with the disaster.

According to estimates, the cost of rebuilding flood-hit areas could swell up to USD 15 billion. As the international community joins hand in pumping aid to Pakistan, vulnerability and helplessness, which the people are facing, is only increasing with time. While the World Food Programme states that destruction of wheat and rice could leave almost 6 million people hungry, reports have already started flooding the media on the impending starvation deaths.

Given that the floods in Pakistan are the worst humanitarian crisis in recent times, dissemination and distribution of aid to the needy population would indeed be a challenge for the government. However, apart from alleviating the material plight of the people, transforming the feudal mindset and operationalising reforms that are much needed to induce fair play and social justice in Pakistani society should be one of the long term priority areas for the civilian government.


 

Monday, August 09, 2010

Joota Kushai ki dastaaan-

Arbab Ghulam Raheem "Joota Kushai"

Bush Baba ki "Joota Kushai"


Zerdari ki "joota kushai"



Dr Sheer Afgan ki "Chitter Prade"

Sunday, August 08, 2010

Why does the PPP not govern? -Shahzad Chaudhry


 
Politics at the moment is about power, not about serving the people. It seems that the president knows the difference well, but he is content to pursue his own plan even if it means handing over the reins to the PML-N at the end of his five years

Within the last two weeks Pakistan has faced three major disasters. An Airblue flight went down in the Margallas, and exposed the inadequacies of the governing structure in proffering an organised effort to search and rescue. We became the laughing stock of the world because of the manner of our non-existent sense of response, capability and capacity in such calamities.

The floods followed soon after, as if giving a lie to the most popular refrain of the previous months, when everyone with a microphone unleashed a volley of abuse against India for imposing `water terrorism' on Pakistan. There are many more reasons for castigating India, but water has rarely been a factual cause. Mostly, we have failed to frame our case on the basis of reality and have been driven by sentiment based on hearsay, and a poor knowledge base of our water issues. Nature compensated us well for the shortages of the previous months with widespread rains, except that we were ill-prepared, as everywhere else, to garner, exploit and use this seasonal gift. What should have been a boon has turned into a bane; hundreds have died, properties lost and the natural cycle of growth, agricultural and industrial, seriously disrupted. A few more billion dollars will be needed to recover from a huge economic setback. Sadly, this too points to an endemic failure of governance, lack of foresight, a dominant sense of laissez-faire in the ruling circles and an entire absence of planning and interest in governing.

Target killings in Karachi are the third chapter of sorrow. Why is there no law being applied? Three days of paralysis in the economic hub of Pakistan has wrought three times the financial loss caused by the unprecedented floods. The floods were God-sent and beyond human intervention, but what about fulfilling a constitutional duty of protecting the life and property of the people of Karachi? Where was the state? Why has the state failed?

This leads me to my question in the title: is the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) actually into governance? I fear not. To my mind, any governance during their current tenure is likely to be incidental, never a planned activity. The PPP and its mandarins will give you many reasons for their plight, chief among these the war on terror, a handover from a military government lacking institutions, a difficult regional environment, and a radicalised society fuelling an uncertain domestic environment. These are a cover for their failures in governance, but a sellable cover all the same. The real reason though is different. It lies in the various fault-lines that retch the party from within, and continue to be perceived as the most imminent business concern within the party's hierarchy. The reasons for the PPP's failures in governance are political in nature, not geo-political, social or security-dominated.

The root of the PPP's perceived nightmares lies in the brutal killing of the iconic Benazir. Three immediate challenges befell the hapless Zardari. Given his own weak reputation within the rank and file of the party, his biggest challenge was to gain and retain control of the party. He must have expected pretenders to unleash their ambitions when Benazir's domineering presence disappeared. Amin Fahim from within and Ghinwa Bhutto and Mumtaz Bhutto from outside the party fold provided substance to his apprehension. Second was the threat to the Bhutto legacy. He, a Zardari and not a Bhutto, meant he needed to reincarnate a Bhutto. Appeared Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, who was anointed the chairperson of the PPP at 18 years. Losing the Bhutto lineage and control over the PPP has been a persistent fear for Zardari. That puts into perspective how both Bilawal and Asifa are being portrayed internationally as the rightful heirs to rule Pakistan. That also explains why the president abdicated his role as the head of the state and instead of relating to people in distress, he opted to head towards Europe to celebrate his son's graduation and to launch him into active politics. There are changes to Bilawal's induction plans, but we have not yet seen the last of them. Zardari's mind is occupied with such issues, rather than aspects of ruling or governance.

Zardari's third challenge was purely political — to maximise the PPP's influence and power base across the national scene. The PML-N's hold over Punjab, and Nawaz Sharif's unquestioned status as a national leader in Benazir's absence, added to Zardari's reason of urgency to counter such a domineering challenge to the PPP's traditional hold. Despite the initial tentativeness and apparent discomfort on both sides to engage, Zardari kept up a pretence of finding common political ground, in reality seeking time to reinforce his political hold, while taking the sting out of the PML-N's opposition. Their combined aversion to military intervention has helped them co-exist, albeit uneasily. Most analyses point to a discreet agreement between the two to avoid berating one another and to let the political system sustain without undue challenge. While Zardari works on entrenching his family's hold over the party and expand its political base, Nawaz Sharif sees a major chink in the PPP armour because of derelict governance, offering him an almost assured return to head the next government. Both seek time-based political agendas. The deal is: no harrying.

With such motives, where is the place for any thought on governance or delivery of service?

Politics at the moment is about power, not about serving the people. It seems that the president knows the difference well, but he is content to pursue his own plan even if it means handing over the reins to the PML-N at the end of his five years. In Zardari's own calculus, time to reinforce control over the party is a bigger imperative than a return to power. Eight years from now Bilawal will be at a more acceptable age to vie for ruling the country. The default dividend in such an arrangement for both parties is an uninterrupted 10 years of democratic rule, helping entrench the political tradition, and distancing the military from habitual intervention.

The 18th Amendment may already be part of law, but the power locus still lies extensively in the Presidency. The prime minister remains a nominated executive and an appointee without authority. The cabinet responds to him only in name, in reality reporting to the president for seeking relevance in the constantly evolving political equation within the party. With both the ministers and the senior bureaucracy looking to the president, and governance farthest from the president's mind, there simply is no governance. Governance is a `demand and supply' function. Ministers deliver governance when the executive demands it. For the moment, the prime minister is dislocated and out of sorts, a forlorn figure, and incapable of governing.

Shahzad Chaudhry is a defence and security analyst
 

Saturday, August 07, 2010

Pakistan in crisis: left to help themselves




Drive along the newish motorway from Islamabad to Peshawar and for a time things seem normal. Until you approach the bridge straddling the Jindi River.

There, on the reservation dividing the two carriageways, is a village created overnight by families who fled there to escape the floodwaters that engulfed them in the night. For eight days they have lived like this, in tatty tents without groundsheets, only a few hours' drive from their country's manicured capital, yet bereft of help from a government seemingly indifferent to their fate.

Saif Ullah is 25 but looks older, aged by a life of near-subsistence farming. Still, the crops of sugar cane, wheat and maize grown on his two hectares of land kept his wife and two young children fed. Then, last week, the Jindi, swollen by torrential rains not witnessed in Pakistan for 80 years, broke its banks, inundating the surrounding villages and farmland.

"I woke up at 3am and got out of bed. I was standing in two feet of water," said Mr Ullah. "People started crying, screaming. We had to swim to the motorway to save ourselves. Our animals drowned."
Mr Ullah can see his ruined house from the road. The few possessions he could call his own lie there under stinking mud and stagnant brown water. A stench of rotting everything – dead animals, contaminated vegetation – fills the nostrils.

The 13 families who inhabited the village of Chatri Tapu slept in the open for a week, with nothing but stones for a bed, until members of the
Kuwaiti Red Crescent
arrived with tents. A bowser provides occasional drinking water, but no food – that comes from motorists who show their pity by throwing packages from their lorries and cars. Drive a little further and the tented village on the motorway, built on a raised embankment, the only high ground around, becomes a town. Scores more tents line the reservation, while animals stand tethered to the crash barrier.

Chaos and Pakistan go together. This country of 170 million souls has plenty to go round. Take the floods, which have killed at least 1,500 people and displaced or affected some 12 million, and add an outbreak of bloody political violence in the port city of Karachi. Then add the ongoing and much bloodier insurgency waged by the Pakistani Taliban in the tribal areas bordering Afghanistan, and you have a potent brew.

Jihadist groups, who this week claimed the life of a senior police officer in Peshawar, blown up by a teenage suicide bomber as he sat in his car, spy an opportunity in the chaos. Islamic charities, most of them relatively moderate but some more extreme, have shown themselves, with Western charities and NGOs, to be the only effective means of relief during the flood crisis, which shows no sign of abating. While the government, hobbled by bureaucracy, remains invisible, the charities, funded by private donations and injections of cash from the Middle East, are only too visible, proclaiming their presence on banners and at roadside help points.
The seeming insensitivity of the Pakistani ruling class is nowhere better illustrated than by the decision of President Asif Ali Zardari to carry on with a visit to Britain, despite the progressive immersion of his country. Standing alongside David Cameron following bilateral discussions at Chequers, President Zardari, widowed husband of Benazir Bhutto and one-time jailbird, brushed aside the controversy sparked by the Prime Minister's description of Pakistan – during a visit to India of all places – as a duplicitous exporter of terrorism.

"This is a friendship that will never break, no matter what happens," Mr Zardari assured the press. "Storms will come and storms will go, and Pakistan and Britain will stand together and face all the difficulties with dignity."
The storms aren't going anywhere, for the moment. The heavy monsoon rains returned to Pakistan yesterday, grounding rescue helicopters – including a small detachment of US Army Chinooks flown in from Afghanistan – and threatening yet more destruction. Since the first floods in the mountainous north, the progress of the disaster has been simple to predict. The Indus, the mighty waterway that forms Pakistan's backbone, is breaking its banks further and further south as the flood waters roar downstream.

In Sindh, the great southern province, 70 villages were flooded within the space of 24 hours yesterday as the flood tide made its way to the Indian Ocean. Around 200,000 people fled their homes, leaving half a million oblivious to the fate approaching them, according to the Pakistani government. The army, the real powerbroker in Pakistan, has deployed some 30,000 troops to help in rescue and relief operations, but outside Peshawar yesterday the only military convoy in sight was a regiment of artillery making its way north.

Nearby, in the town of Pabbi, 800 refugees crowded into a decaying high school converted into an aid post by the Al Khidmat Foundation, a charity affiliated to the Islamic Jamaat-i-Islami Party. Shahid Wali Khattak, the charity's tall, bearded, imposing general secretary, was scathing about the government's performance.
Maybe these rains are a test from Allah, a test of those who claim to help the people. Zardari – where is he? In Britannia. The government is not here; it has done nothing for these people. We must help ourselves More extreme is the Falah-e-Insaniat Foundation, which is carrying out relief work in the province of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, known until recently as North-West Frontier Province. Falah is an offshoot of the Jamaat-ud-Dawa charity, which in turn is accused of being a reincarnation of the Lashkar-e-Taiba group responsible for the 2008 terrorist attacks in Mumbai.

The poor farmers made destitute by the floods are in no mood to worry about the credentials of those helping them. More than 252,000 homes are thought to have been damaged or destroyed across Pakistan, and 558,000 hectares of agricultural land flooded.

Mohammad Bakhsh is one of the faceless millions. "Our cattle died and the cotton crop was destroyed," he said. "I've got calls on my mobile saying 20 to 25 children from our family are stranded in the village and are holding on to tree branches. Two of my children have drowned and we don't know where they are."

Outside Peshawar, Afghan refugees driven from their country by the fighting of the 1980s have been left to fend for themselves, colonising the raised railway line to escape the flood waters. Stinking mud-soaked blankets lay on the sodden ground yesterday, their only rescued possessions.

Shah Wali, 28, was in despair: "We have never been helped and we are again alone." Yet adults managed to laugh as boys chased parcels tossed from cars. Others scrambled out of the way as the Peshawar to Rawalpindi express chugged into view.

With masterly understatement, army Major-General Athar Abbas summarised the situation. "We do not have the kind of resources to cope with a situation like this, and I think the international community should come to our help."
Zardari, the frontman for the army, is on trial. Waiting in the wings is General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, chief of the general staff and the man the Americans listen to. He has just been granted an unprecedented second three-year term in office. The army is said to be the only institution that really works in Pakistan – a debatable proposition, given its own performance during the floods.

Zardari is this weekend meant to be anointing his son, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, who turns 22 next month, as the next inheritor of the Bhutto political legacy at a rally in Birmingham. In order to minimise the domestic fallout from his father's foreign sojourn, Bilawal will instead be attending a fundraising event in London in aid of the flood victims.

But there is no doubt that Zardari's reputation at home is tarnished. The News newspaper put it thus: "When millions are drowning in flash floods and when Karachi is burning in a bloodbath and when terrorists are roaming around with abandon, he has decided to insult the nation by his abrasiveness and arrogance."

Zardari, with his wealth, is at one end of the spectrum; Gulab Rahim is at the other. Surveying the ruin of his home, he said: "Our whole life passed in difficulties and we have never seen prosperity. May Allah give us happiness in the life hereafter."
 

Pakistani floods: A man-made not a natural disaster

Pakistani floods: A man-made not a natural disaster



 The tragedy unfolding in Pakistan as a result of the country’s worst floods in 80 years is a devastating indictment not only of the present Pakistani government, but of its international allies—the US in particular—and the profit system as a whole. While the torrential rains have been caused by natural forces, the human disaster has been compounded by decades of government neglect and the lack of planning and infrastructure.

National Disaster Management Authority head Nadim Ahmed yesterday put the number of people affected so far at 12 million, with 650,000 homes destroyed over some 132,000 square kilometres. The official death toll is 1,500 and rising. Hundreds of thousands of people are still stranded without shelter or supplies of food and clean water.

The floodwaters that have already savaged northwestern Pakistan are surging down the Indus river system towards the country’s south. At least 70 towns and villages have been inundated over the past 48 hours. Half a million people have been evacuated and 11 districts in Sindh are on the danger list. Weather forecasters are predicting further heavy rains, raising the prospect of even more flooding.

Already there is widespread anger over the absence of warnings or preparation and the utter inadequacy of the rescue and relief effort. Scores of news articles report flood victims huddled in makeshift shelters criticising the government for failing to provide even elementary aid. Referring to Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari’s current trip to Britain, columnist Ayesha Tammy Haz commented: “When he returns to Pakistan, there’s going to be a river of resentment brimming over, just as high as his brimming smile.”

Opposition politicians and the media have lambasted Zardari for failing to cancel his European trip while millions suffer in Pakistan. “It is disgusting to see Zardari going on a joy ride when people here expected the president to stand with the nation at its hour of grief,” opposition lawmaker Ahsan Iqbal told the Washington Post. Already accused of indifference, Zardari declared after meeting British Prime Minister David Cameron that “storms will come and storms will go”—referring to troubled British-Pakistani relations—but the choice of words was highly insensitive, to say the least.

Undoubtedly Zardari’s decision to proceed with his visit reflects the disdain and contempt of the ruling elites towards the country’s impoverished masses. But it also points to the deeper political crises wracking his government, which is already despised for its proxy war against Islamist militants on behalf of Washington, and austerity policies dictated by the International Monetary Fund that have compounded the social crisis facing tens of millions.

Zardari rushed off to Britain to patch up relations after the British prime minister pointedly criticised the Pakistani government for “looking both ways” when it came to “terrorism”. The criticism was all the more bitter because Cameron was speaking during an official visit to Pakistan’s neighbour and regional rival, India. While reaffirming close ties, Cameron’s comments were part of efforts being led by the US to pressure Zardari to intensify the military’s unpopular war in the border areas with Afghanistan.

Zardari is already walking a political knife-edge—dependent on American political, economic and military support on the one hand, but facing widespread popular opposition over the US-led military operations in Pakistan and Afghanistan. According to a poll last month by the Pew Global Attitudes Project, only 20 percent of Pakistanis regarded Zardari positively, down from 64 percent when he came to office two years ago. In addition, 59 percent described the US as an enemy and only 17 percent had a favourable view of the US.

In the flood-affected areas of Pakistan that have already been embroiled in war—such as the Swat Valley—the levels of disgust and anger are certain to be much higher. Just over a year ago, the Pakistani military poured more than 20,000 troops into the Swat Valley and neighbouring areas in a bid to crush Islamist militias. At least two million people were displaced, with hundreds of thousands forced to shelter in overcrowded and squalid refugee camps. Now many of these people face the same situation again.

The overriding concern in Washington over the flooding has been with its potential impact on the so-called AfPak war. Commentators have warned of the danger that Islamist organisations could take advantage of the government’s limited relief operation to gain support by offering their own aid. Others have urged the Obama administration to exploit the opportunity to boost the image of the US by providing assistance.

These cynical calculations recall the comments of US Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice following the December 2004 tsunumi that devastated Sri Lanka, Indonesia and other countries, leaving hundreds of thousands dead and millions homeless. Rice declared that the tragedy represented “an opportunity” for the US to lift its profile. In Sri Lanka, the Bush administration used the tsunami to deploy American troops to the island for the first time, and to consolidate ties with the Sri Lankan military.

Likewise the Obama administration’s aid is driven by US strategic interests. Significantly, US military helicopters have been deployed to flood-affected areas inside Pakistan. To maintain a semblance of independence, the Pakistani government and military have previously limited the presence of American military forces inside the country. As for humanitarian aid, the US has promised a pittance—lifting the initial pledge of $US10 million to just $US25 million on Thursday. By contrast, the US Congress last week approved an additional $60 billion for military operations in neighbouring Afghanistan.

The disaster in Pakistan is the product of years of neglect. Monsoons are an annual event and floods occur regularly, yet successive governments have failed to develop proper flood warning systems and flood control measures. Infrastructure has not been planned to deal with natural disasters, whether the current flooding or the devastating 2005 earthquake in Kashmir. As in the case of Hurricane Katrina in the US in 2005, and the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, rational planning is impossible under a social order dominated by private profit and the anarchy of the market. Those worst affected are inevitably the poorest layers of society.

Responsibility for the flood catastrophe should certainly be sheeted home to the Pakistani government and political establishment. But the impoverished character of countries like Pakistan is also the product of more than a century of imperialist oppression. The social gulf between rich and poor has been exacerbated over the past three decades by the globalisation of production and the transformation of Pakistan into a cheap labour platform. In the wake of the global economic crisis, international finance capital is demanding savage cuts to government spending that will only lead to a further deterioration of social infrastructure.

Moreover the communal partition of British India in 1947 into Muslim Pakistan and predominantly Hindu India has placed insuperable barriers before the establishment of a comprehensive flood management system for these rivers that cross the national borders. While the two rivals continue their bitter dispute over control of the Indus River, flooding has hit, not only Pakistan but now Indian-controlled Kashmir, where at least 100 were killed yesterday.

The latest disaster is another tragic demonstration of the incompatibility of the profit system with the elementary needs of ordinary working people. The only solution is an internationalist and socialist one—the independent mobilisation of workers in Pakistan and throughout South Asia and the globe to abolish capitalism and replace it with a world planned socialist economy that will consciously allocate the resources necessary to minimise the impact of natural events such as floods and earthquakes.

Wije Dias




Sunday, July 18, 2010

Pakistan: a client of more than one state By Mustafa Qadri

China has been Pakistan's firmest ally for 60 years – and it is to Beijing that Islamabad looks to counterbalance the influence of western largesse

Pakistan's special relationship with the United States may have taken centre stage since the attacks of 11 September 2001, but in China it has another enduring great power ally. With Pakistan's President Zardari returning from a visit of several days to China last week, it is worth considering the country's other asymmetrical alliance.

China has been Pakistan's most reliable ally for six decades. Pakistan was quick to recognise China's communist regime a mere two years after it first came to power in 1949. Ever since, it has looked to the east Asian power to counterbalance its historical reliance on western geopolitical largesse.

After the 1962 war between China and India, the US supplied India for the first time with substantial arms, creating profound disenchantment among the Pakistani military leadership. That disenchantment led Pakistan to seek Chinese military aid.

In the last two decades the economic component of the alliance has taken centre stage. Pakistan has the potential to give China a land link to Middle Eastern energy reserves. A central reason for US involvement in the region is to maintain its global influence at a time when rivals are steadily if slowly emerging. None is larger than China. For China, an added element is developing a regional coalition against an increasingly pro-US India.

Today, the relationship is not so culturally infused. As with so many other countries, China has been happy to develop defence and economic ties with Pakistan while avoiding criticism of its political situation. Perhaps the biggest friction of recent times has been over alleged Pakistan-based Islamist infiltration into China's restive Xinjiang province, home to the indigenous Uighur Muslim population. That friction prompted a visit by Pakistan's most powerful Islamist politicians to assure Beijing that they would not stoke Islamist insurgency in China.

Those concerns, however, have proved shortlived. Pakistan has been busy integrating its economy into China, although it has generally been slow going. The much-vaunted deep sea port built in restive Balochistan with the apparent aim of giving a Chinese presence at the mouth of the Persian Gulf has barely scratched its full potential. Expansion of the
Karakoram Highway
that links northern Pakistan to China seems to have been in development for decades.

Less incremental was the recent announcement that China will sell nuclear reactors to Pakistan. A $2.4bn deal hopes to quench Pakistan's thirst for energy, and recognition as a responsible nuclear citizen on the world stage.

There are thinly veiled concerns that the agreement could be in breach of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Despite this, the US, on whose words and action so much of western policy in our region is determined, has offered only limited criticisms. This may have something to do with theUS and India deal that would see the former reprocess spent nuclear fuel for the latter, although India got an exemption from the Nuclear Suppliers Group for that purpose.

In Balochistan, Pakistan's largest and most resource-rich province, China has been busy trying to exploit coal, copper, and zinc deposits and gas and oil reserves. The indigenous Baloch population says these ventures systematically disenfranchise them. Pakistan authorities counter claim that, emboldened by countrywide instability and foreign support, Baloch feudal leaders have petulantly demanded ever more royalties. An increasingly brutal insurgency and counterinsurgency has developed around this resource politics. After some sobering experiences involving the kidnapping and murder of its nationals, China has learned to accept the bribery culture that keeps both Pakistani and Baloch tribal leaders happy.

China's relationship to our region stretches back at least 2,000 to the period when scholars and traders introduced Buddhism from what is now Pakistan to the Middle Kingdom, an episode of history celebrated in Chinese literature and the Monkey TV series. Yet in the intervening centuries, the relationship has not had any major cultural or ideological impact on Pakistan, as noted in a satirical poem by the great dissident poet Habib Jalib.

Like Pakistan's current robust relations with the US, this is because China-Pakistan relations have largely been dictated by elite notions of the national interest and prestige. China may still be happy to play second fiddle to the US here. But with polls revealing Pakistan'soverwhelmingly favourable view of its northern neighbour and continued western missteps in Afghanistan, the dispiriting reality is that our country is a client of more than one state.

 

Sunday, July 11, 2010

Babar Awan's university not recognised by HEC

   The Higher Education Commission (HEC) has informed the National Assembly's Standing Committee on Education that the University of Monticello, US, from where Law Minister Babar Awan claims to have done his PhD, is a non-recognised and non-chartered university, it is learnt.

HEC Chairman Javed Leghari, when approached, confirmed on Saturday that the commission had recently received a formal query from the NA Committee on Education Chairman Abid Sher Ali regarding the standing of the University of Monticello and its mandate to offer PhD programmes. Leghari disclosed that the HEC verification proved the university was non-recognized and non-chartered. "We have formally informed the NA committee chairman about the fact," Leghari said.

According to sources, Abid Sher Ali had recently approached the HEC to verify the standing of the university after the media reports about the dubious status of Babar Awan's doctorate. Although `The News' broke the story of Babar Awan PhD degree as being fake in November 2008, the HEC's letter to the NA Committee on Education chairman regarding the standing of the Monticello University is the official confirmation of the fact.

It is yet to be seen as to how the NA committee or the Election Commission of Pakistan would proceed as it involves a federal minister, who appears to be more powerful than even the prime minister because of his close association with the president.

It is pertinent to note here that the United States Educational Foundation (USEF) in Pakistan has already confirmed that the University of Monticello was never allowed to offer degree programmes, including PhD. "It was a fraud," the USEF Pakistan has written to this newspaper when approached in Nov 2008.

The minister, however, while admitting to have done his PhD from the same university insisted that his doctorate degree was genuine. However, the latest finding of the HEC about the Monticello University, now formally conveyed to the NA committee, is a subtle disclaimer of the Government of Pakistan to the minister's claim. In his letter, the Standing Committee on Education chairman only inquired about the university and did not name the minister.

When asked if the commission would also verify the post-graduation and PhD degrees of MPs who claim to have done masters and PhD, the HEC chairman said such questions do not pertain to the commission, which is only there to do the verification work.

Leghari assured that the HEC would honestly and professionally do its work without any fear and favour or taking into consideration political pressure from any side. He said the verification of the degrees of parliamentarians, already referred to the commission, would be completed by July 16. Leghari said the universities concerned had been given the deadline of 13th of July to send their reports on the degrees already referred to them.

According to the HEC chairman, out of the 161 cases of degrees of parliamentarians referred back to the Election Commission of Pakistan recently, degrees of 20 parliamentarians are still missing while the ECP has submitted the degrees of the remaining ones.
 

Saturday, July 10, 2010

Israel is recognized by PAKISTAN?

The world Zionist movement should not be neglectful of the dangers of Pakistan to it. And Pakistan now should be its first target, for this ideological State is a threat to our existence. And Pakistan, the whole of it, hates the Jews and loves the Arabs. This lover of the Arabs is more dangerous to us than the Arabs themselves. For that matter, it is most essential for the world Zionism that it should now take immediate steps against Pakistan.” Ben-Gurion, the Prime Minister of Israel.

This speech was first published in Jewish Chronicles on 9th August 1967. This statement risen many controversies   various explanations were also given to disprove this statement, but still we read it on every article related to Pakistan and Israel.

Pakistan and Israel do share some history and ideology. These are only two countries in the world created in the name of Religion; Pakistan for Islam, Israel for Judaism and both countries have taken independence from same British Empire after World War II.

Pakistan claimed its independence from foreign invaders after two centuries of struggle. In 1757 after Battle of Plassey, East India Company started ruling Indian Sub-continent. The first armed resistance was Battle of Independence in 1857 after which the power was transferred to British government. In 1885 the political movement of independence started as Indian National Congress. Some of the Muslim leaders soon separated and launched new movement in 1906 as All India Muslim League for separate Muslim state which led to the creation of independent Islamic state Pakistan on 14th August 1947, which then became Islamic Republic of Pakistan in 1973.

For Israel the timings was same and the rulers were also same as of Indian sub-continents, but events and circumstances were totally different. Israel declared its independence on 14th May 1948 from British Mandate of Palestine. But Israel independence movement was not against British Occupation; rather it was a movement of creating a Jewish State by silently invading the markets, trades and areas to make Jewish settlements. Hovevei Zion or Hibbat Zion refers to organizations that are considered the foundations of the modern Zionist movement. These movements led to creation of Rishon LeZion in 1882 which is the first Jewish settlement in Palestine; which was at that time under Ottoman Empire. First Zionist Congress held in 1897 started the unified Zionist Movement which was converted to World Zionist Organisation in 1960. This movement was successful in legalizing its demand of separate Jewish state in Palestine after Balfour Declaration 1917, in which British Mandate of Palestine’s (1917 – 1948) foreign Secretary Arhur James Balfour wrote letter to the leader of British Jewish Community Baron Rothschild, pledging British Empire support of creation of Jewish State in Palestinian Land.

So what kind of relationship does Pakistan and Israel has over period of 60 years?

While writing this blog I also tried to ask couple Pakistanis; their view points about Pakistan-Israel Relationship. Yousaf is Pakistani Engineer living and working in Saudi Arabia. Being in the region, Pakistanis here are emotionally and regionally attached to Middle East crisis. I asked him what kind of relationship both countries have. “Relationship between Pakistan and Israel are tied to the fact that how Israel government treats the Palestinians. In general, as Jerusalem is considered as one of the holiest places in Islam; this fact serves as a thorn in the eyes of Pakistanis.” Yousaf said.

Pakistan is among those 20 UN member nations which do not recognise Israel as an independent state. These 20 countries also include Afghanistan, Algeria, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Chad, Cuba, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Malaysia, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Syria, United Arab Emirates and Yemen. Unofficial media reports say that first Prime Minister of Israel David Ben-Gurion send secret message to Muhammad Ali Jinnah to formally accept its existence, but no response was given back to him. At the time of independence of Pakistan, it was reported that some 2,000 Jews remained in Pakistan, mostly Bene Yisrale Jews. Many left to Israel after its declaration of independence. Jews from Karachi, Pakistan, now live in Ramla, Israel, and they also built a synagogue they named Magen Shalome after the Pakistani Synagogue which was demolished in 1980.

60s, 70s and beginning of 80s were the decades when for the first time both countries came face to face when Arab-Israel war started. In “Six-day Arab Israeli War” of 1967; Royal Jordanian Air Force (RJAF) and Pakistan Air Force (PAF) were flying under a joint command. PAF pilot Flt. Lt. Saiful Azam became the only pilot from the Arab side to have shot down 3 IDF/AF aircraft within 72 hours.

In 1973 Arab-Israeli Yom Kippur War, 16 PAF pilots volunteered to support Syria and Egypt. On 23 October 1973 Flt. Lt. M. Hatif shot down the Israeli Phantom. On 26 April 1974, PAF pilot Flt. Lt. A. Sattar Alvi became the first Pakistani pilot, during the Yom Kippur War; to shoot down an Israeli Mirage in air combat. He was honoured by the Syrian government. Nur Khan, who was the Wing Commander received praised from Israeli President Ezer Weizman who wrote in his autobiography that: “He was a formidable fellow and I was glad that he was Pakistani and not Egyptian”. Pakistan also sent medical ambulances to Egypt and Syria.

After the Israeli attack on Iraq’s under-construction French-built nuclear Osirak-type reactor, Tammuz-I, south of Baghdad on 7 June 1981, Pakistan’s then President President Zia-ul-Haq directed PAF Air Headquarters (AHQ) to make contingency plans for a possible Israeli attack on Kahuta. Kahuta is noted for its nuclear research studies and nuclear development technologies in Kahuta Research Laboratories. On 10 July 1982, a special contingency plan was issued. In the event of an Israeli attack on Pakistan’s strategic installations, plans were drawn up for a retaliatory Pakistani strike on Negev Nuclear Research Centre. The Negev Nuclear Research Centre is an Israeli nuclear installation located in the Negev desert, about thirteen kilometres to the south-east of the city of Dimona.

On political level many statements were given. As chair of the Second Islamic Summit in 1974, then Pakistan’s Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto said: “To Jews as Jews we bear no malice; to Jews as Zionists, intoxicated with their militarism and reeking with technological arrogance, we refuse to be hospitable.”

In of his speeches in National Assembly of Pakistan, before Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was hanged in 1979, he said, “Mr. Speaker Sir! This is not Desi (local) conspiracy, it’s an international conspiracy. Let me make it quite clear for the history, whatever the future and fate of this individual will be; that doesn’t matter, but let me tell you again this is not a desi (local) conspiracy, this is not PNA conspiracy, this is massive, huge and colossal international conspiracy against the Islamic State of Pakistan.” (PNA was Pakistan National Alliance against the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party). Nowadays people like to refer this international controversy as Zionist or Israeli Conspiracy.

A controversial book was published in 2003, named Charlie’s Wilson war which conspire about use of Israeli weapons supplied to General Zia ul Haq to fight Soviets in Afghanistan (1979 – 1989). Famous Hollywood movie Charlie’s Wilson War was also released in 2007. After that the back door politics started between Pakistan and Israel.

The President of Pakistan General Zia ul Haq was assassinated in plane crash on 17 August 1988. Among the conspiracy theories; Mossad (Israeli Intelligence Agency) involvement is also believed to exist. In the fall 2005 World Policy Journal, John Gunther Dean, a former US ambassador to India, blamed the Mossad for orchestrating Zia’s assassination in retaliation for Pakistan developing a nuclear weapon to counteract India and Israel.

Ali is my friend living in Middle East. I asked him, can there ever be any friendship or peace between Pakistan and Israel, to which he replied, “Yes there can be, Israel is a small country with a group of people belonging to a group of faith. And also it is in its interest that it should be at peace with every country, and especially those countries that it feels can threaten its existence.”

It is believed that, at the time of Benazir Bhutto’s Government both countries had very strong relationship especially in countering terrorism. In 1993 Benazir Bhutto, along with her then-Director-General of Military Operations, Pervez Musharraf, intensified the ISI’s liaison with Mossad in 1993, and she too began to cultivate the American Jewish lobby. Bhutto is said to have had a secret meeting in New York with a senior Israeli diplomat, who flew to the U.S. during her visit to Washington, D.C. in 1995.

In 1996, Pakistan’s Intelligence Agency, FIA, started a secret war against Extremist in Pakistan under Rehman Malik. According to sources, FIA also contacted Israeli intelligence agency Mossad to help and send its officers to investigate the extremism. Even after these strong ties, controversies never left the scenario. Benazir Bhutto was assassinated on 27 December 2007 in one political rally. This was considered to be typical Mossad Assassination style. It is believed that she was the one knowing the reality of 9/11 being inside job and death of Osama Bin Laden, which she also publicly stated in David Frost TV program. That program was edited before telecasting. But Jewish Journals and Media still believed in the opposite way. According to Jewish media, Miss Bhutto asked for Mossad help to protect her on her return to Pakistan as she was afraid she will be killed.

In 1998 Pakistan and Israel were again on the verge of war. On 27 May 1998, day before Pakistan conducted its nuclear test in Chaghi, Southern Province of Balochistan, Pakistan; unidentified F-16 was found hovering around skies on border areas of Pakistan. Pakistan Air Force; taking is as repetition of Israeli Conspiracy similar to 1981, Air Bourne its fighters to foil any attack. But Pakistan and Israeli UN delegation met in UN soon after Pakistan Nuclear tests in 1998 to give assurance that Pakistan will not transfer its technologies to Iran, the arch enemy of Israel.

Musharraf’s nine years of rule was also golden times for both countries. In 2003, General Pervaiz Musharraf said on television interview, “Mainly Muslim Pakistan must seriously take up the issue of recognizing Israel and avoid dealing with it on emotional grounds”. This statement gave birth to local opposition, esp. among Religious Parties in Pakistan. “Jerusalem is not just an Arab issue, it is linked to the faith of every Muslim” said Qazi Hussain Ahmed, chief of Jamaat-i-Islami Pakistan, the largest and oldest religious political party. “Presenting Palestine as a sole Arab issue is a heinous conspiracy of the imperialists and colonists aimed at disintegrating the Muslims and shattering the concept of Muslim unity. It is for the same reason the colonist forces are trying to portray every Muslim issue as regional or bilateral” said Qazi.

In 2005 Pakistani Foreign Minister Khurshid Kasuri and his Israeli counterpart Silvan Shalom met in Istanbul after Israel withdrew its forces from Gaza, Palestine hoping to start peace talks. However, following the meeting Musharraf said, “Pakistan will not recognise the state of Israel until an independent Palestinian state is established”.

An unofficial Pakistan-Israel Peace Forum was created the next day of the meeting. It was created by 3 friends Waleed Ziad (Pakistan), Dror Topf (Israel), and Michael Berenhaus (US), all currently based in Washington, DC. This forum was an unsuccessful attempt to lobby in UN, US, Israel and Pakistani political establishments, hoping that Pakistani might accept Israel as independent legal state.

Pakistan and Israel are also secretly involved in Weapons and Arms Development Race. Close ties between India and Israel, and arms business between them forces Pakistan to keep an eye on Israel’s weapons industry. Like for example; Pakistan Ordinance Factory (POF) developed POF Eye Gun and exhibited in 2008 to counter the Israeli made Cornershot Rifle which is also known as Jews Gun in Arab World.

Shall Pakistan recognise Israel as an independent state to which Yousaf and Ali shared the same answer, “Pakistan should only consider recognizing Israel if it gives an independent state to the Palestinians with Jerusalem at its capital. And completely cut off itself from the internal affairs of that state, only then Pakistan should even start to consider recognizing them.”

I thought why not to ask some of Palestinians who have been living in exile for almost six decades. Abdul-Rahman is originally from Nabulus, West Bank and Qasim is from Gaza. I asked them what role Pakistan can play any role in solving Middle East Crisis, to which Abdul Rahman replied, “May be or may be not. Pakistan has its own problems with India, in Kashmir and in Afghanistan.” And Qasim said, “Pakistan cannot play any role especially with the current government which is only thinking of business but not Islam or Muslims.” Which actually hit me hard but truth is truth. On inquiring the Pakistan’s nuclear threat to Israel, Abdul Rahman said, “Israelis are even scared of stones so obviously Israel want end to Pakistan’s Nuclear technology, the Islamic Bomb.” But Qasim stuck to his same point, “If Pakistani government wants it can use nuclear technology against Israel, not in war or something but also to play politics.” Then in the end I asked, shall Pakistan Recognise Israel as independent country. Both of them came up with different and interesting answers. Abdul Rahman said, “There is should be a procedure of acceptance. Israel should balance the power and control of every city between themselves and Palestinians, then Pakistan can recognize Israel.” Whereas Qasim said, “Pakistan should recognise Israel. Sitting outside and ending any communication will not resolve the Middle East problem. We need to enter the region to solve the problem and if Pakistan wants it can do that by taking first step of recognising Israel.”

It was interesting journey going through all the historic events which Pakistan and Israel share and knowing different ideas and opinions. All these events which I have mentioned above, cannot be confirmed from any credible or authentic source as all this happened back stage, behind the camera. But whatever governments’ relationship may be it is true that people of Pakistan still want to call every conspiracy as Zionist conspiracy and this will keep on going until some peaceful solution is devised to Middle East crisis between Muslim Palestinians and Jewish Israelis.

Contributed by Junaid


Text Widget